If your mortgage renews this fall, you are choosing at an awkward moment. Fixed rates have gone up at every big bank since September. Variable rates have not moved, because the Bank of Canada has held its rate at 2.25 per cent since last October. As of October 8, 2026, the best 5-year variable rate is 3.40 per cent and the best 5-year fixed rate is 4.34 per cent.
That gap of almost a full point is the whole decision. Variable is cheaper today. Fixed protects you if the Bank of Canada starts raising rates, which bond markets now expect. Below we put both options through a real renewal so you can see what the gap is worth in dollars.
Why fixed rates went up
Fixed mortgage rates follow the 5-year Government of Canada bond yield, not the Bank of Canada. That yield was 2.67 per cent on February 27, just before the war with Iran pushed oil prices sharply higher. It closed at 3.68 per cent on September 28, its highest level in a year, and was trading near 3.67 per cent on October 7 as Brent crude went back above US$100.
Lenders passed it on. CIBC and TD raised select 3- and 5-year fixed rates by 20 basis points on September 29. BMO, National Bank, RBC and Scotiabank had already raised theirs in the weeks before, and RBC raised again by 10 to 20 basis points in the first week of October. The posted 5-year rate at the big banks, which is used to calculate many penalties, reached 6.19 per cent on October 7.
| Rate | Today |
|---|---|
| Best 5-year variable | 3.40% (prime minus 1.05) |
| Best 5-year fixed | 4.34% |
| Best 3-year fixed | 4.34% |
| Lowest big-bank 5-year fixed | 4.74% |
| Prime rate | 4.45% |
| Bank of Canada policy rate | 2.25% |
| 5-year bond yield | about 3.6% |
Advertised rates are mostly for insured mortgages. On a renewal with more than 20 per cent equity, expect quotes 0.10 to 0.30 points higher.
What each choice costs on a $500,000 renewal
Take a $500,000 balance with 20 years left to pay. Here is the monthly payment and the interest you would pay over the next five years if nothing changed.
| Option | Rate | Monthly payment | Interest over 5 years |
|---|---|---|---|
| Best variable | 3.40% | $2,868 | $76,715 |
| Big-bank variable | 3.65% | $2,931 | $82,503 |
| Best fixed | 4.34% | $3,110 | $98,562 |
| Big-bank fixed | 4.74% | $3,216 | $107,925 |
If rates stayed put, the best variable would save about $242 a month and close to $22,000 in interest over the term compared with the best fixed rate. The question is how likely rates are to stay put.

How far rates must rise for fixed to win
We ran the same $500,000 renewal with the variable rate rising at different speeds.
| What the Bank of Canada does | Variable interest over 5 years | Compared with 4.34% fixed |
|---|---|---|
| Holds for five years | $76,715 | Variable saves $21,800 |
| Two hikes, 0.50 points in total | $87,655 | Variable saves $10,900 |
| Four hikes in the next year, 1.00 point | $98,223 | About even |
| Six hikes, 1.50 points | $107,237 | Fixed saves $8,700 |
The break-even is about one full percentage point of increases, arriving within the first year and staying for the rest of the term. Smaller or slower increases still leave variable ahead. If rates rise and later fall, variable does better than this table shows.
What markets and economists expect
This is where the decision gets harder. Bond markets are pricing roughly one percentage point of Bank of Canada increases over the next 12 months. That is almost exactly the break-even above.
Economists are less sure. Scotiabank expects a hike on October 28. RBC and Desjardins expect the Bank to hold through 2026 and start raising in early 2027. TD has said the case for a hike is “not that compelling.” Capital Economics called markets’ pricing excessive. Our Bank of Canada October 28 preview covers the data the Bank will be looking at.
Mortgage brokers are watching borrowers vote with their feet. One broker told Canadian Mortgage Trends that more than 60 per cent of his clients are now choosing variable. Historically, about 60 per cent of Canadians took a 5-year fixed.
Who should lean variable
- You could absorb a payment $250 to $400 higher on a $500,000 balance without strain. That is what a 1 to 1.5 point rise would cost.
- You might sell or refinance within five years. Breaking a variable mortgage usually costs three months’ interest. Breaking a fixed one can cost far more, because of the interest rate differential calculated off the bank’s posted rate.
- You plan to make lump-sum payments. The lower rate means more of every extra dollar goes to principal.
Who should lean fixed
- Your budget is already tight. If a $300 jump in your payment would cause real trouble, the certainty is worth paying for.
- Your payment jumped a lot at this renewal. Many people renewing now took 5-year fixed rates near 2 per cent in 2021. On a $600,000 mortgage taken at 2.09 per cent, the payment was about $2,567. The balance today is about $503,600, and renewing at 4.34 per cent fixed takes the payment to $3,132. Variable at 3.40 per cent brings it to $2,889. If the first increase already hurts, do not add rate risk on top.
- You will not watch rates. Variable works best for people who will read the Bank of Canada news and lock in if needed.
A middle option: the 3-year fixed
The best 3-year fixed rate is currently the same as the best 5-year at 4.34 per cent. A shorter term lets you renew again in 2029, when today’s rate fears may have passed. Some lenders also offer a hybrid, splitting the mortgage half fixed and half variable.
Five steps for a fall renewal
- Start 120 days before maturity. Most lenders let you renew or hold a rate in that window without penalty. If rates fall during the hold, most will give you the lower rate.
- Do not sign the first letter. Your bank’s renewal offer is rarely its best rate. Ask for a better one, and get quotes elsewhere.
- Switching lenders is easier than it was. A straight switch with the same balance and amortization no longer requires the stress test. It applies to uninsured mortgages since November 2024 and to insured ones after the federal change that December. See our stress test guide.
- Compare at the same amortization. A lower payment from a longer amortization is not a lower rate.
- If you take variable, ask about the conversion option. Most lenders let you lock into a fixed rate at any time without a penalty, at their rate on that day.
Our full list of 5-year variable mortgage rates is updated as lenders move, and the mortgage payment calculator will show your own number.
Questions about renewing this fall
Are fixed mortgage rates going up in Canada?
Yes. All of the big six banks raised fixed rates between September and early October 2026 as the 5-year bond yield climbed to a one-year high near 3.7 per cent. Some brokers expect a big-bank 5-year fixed rate starting with a 5 before the end of the year.
Is variable cheaper than fixed right now?
Yes, by almost a full point. The best 5-year variable is 3.40 per cent and the best 5-year fixed is 4.34 per cent.
How much would rates have to rise for fixed to be better?
About one percentage point of Bank of Canada increases within the first year, held for the rest of the five-year term.
Can I switch lenders at renewal without the stress test?
Yes, on a straight switch with the same balance and amortization.
How early can I renew?
Most lenders allow it in the last 120 days of your term without a penalty.
Sources and method
- Mortgage rates: Ratehub.ca, October 8, 2026. Prime rate and big-bank fixed rate from the same source.
- Bond yields and posted rate: Bank of Canada daily data, series BD.CDN.5YR.DQ.YLD and V80691335.
- Bank rate changes: Canadian Mortgage Trends, September 29, October 1 and October 7, 2026; Money.ca, September 29, 2026.
- Economist views: Canadian Press, September 18, 2026; Money.ca, October 8, 2026; Canadian Mortgage Trends, October 1, 2026.
- Stress test exemption for switches: Office of the Superintendent of Financial Institutions.
- Payments and interest calculated by Local Toronto with semi-annual compounding. Variable scenarios recalculate the payment after each rate change.
Local Toronto is not a mortgage lender or broker. This page is general information, not mortgage advice. HomeLife Landmark Realty Inc., Brokerage.
